Category Archives: Buddy vs. Duff

Holiday decor in Team Buddy's bakery, as seen on Buddy vs Duff Holiday, Season 4.

The Winner of Buddy vs. Duff Holiday is… Plus the 5 Best Moments!

The friendly rivalry between these west and east coast bakers takes on a new sweetness in this season of Buddy vs. Duff Holiday: both Buddy Valastro (Carlo’s Bakery) and Duff Goldman (Charm City Cakes) are playing for a  $25,000 donation to their favourite charity (Buddy chooses Toys for Tots and Duff picks Off Their Plate).

Host Buddy Valastro checks in with Team Duff before working on their "Nutcracker"-themed cake, as seen on Buddy vs Duff Holiday, Season 4.

Judges Elizabeth Faulkner and Gesine Prado are in New York, and pastry chef Stephanie Boswell and chocolatier Valerie Gordon are in Los Angeles to help judge the festive creations. Although Duff’s team ends up winning 145 to 139, Buddy still gets $10,000 to donate to his charity, in the full spirit of the holidays.

Both teams pull out all the stops in this four-episode battle, trying new chemistry experiments with isomalt and poured epoxy resin, crafting goofy and realistic animals and generally having a lot of fun along the way. In the true spirit of the holidays, let’s take a look at the five best moments that embodied festive-fun (tinged with a little bit of stress).

Host Duff Goldman shaves cake for table top, as seen on Buddy vs Duff, Season 4.

Double Take

Skating into the finale, Duff’s team leads by only one point, so the stakes are high. When Buddy proposes a winter wonderland theme, both teams immediately think of an Arctic scene with penguins and polar bears, meaning that they are both making essentially the same cake a fact that they discover mid-way through the 20-hour bake. “We’ve already started, and it’s too late to change our design, so we’ve got to go with it,” says  Buddy ruefully.  Happily, the cakes couldn’t look more different: Duff’s team plays to their strengths in sculpting with hyper-realistic looking animals and birds, while Buddy takes a more whimsical and cartoonish approach to their critters. “I don’t want to give the feeling like he’s going to start chowing down on penguins,” says Buddy’s cake artist Anna Puchalski when creating her goofy looking polar bear. “It’s the holidays, it’s not winter wonder murder.”

Moving Parts

Already hard at work making Charm City Cake’s massive five-foot polar bear, cake artists Sonny Robinson and Natalie Sideserf are challenged even further when Duff decides that the 64 square foot cake base needs more animals. The team ends up adding three seals and another bear (the more the merrier, after all).

The Carlo’s Bakery team gets ambitious with a moving bear coming out of the water with a fish in its mouth: a piece of machinery head sculptor Ralph Attanasia  has great fun testing. “It’s definitely scientific and not because it’s fun,” he jokes, as he hops onto the platform and poses in his best bear imitation. “I’ve got a fishy in my mouth!” he roars.

Related: Cake Boss Buddy Valastro is Bringing a Bakery to Toronto

Chemistry Experiments

A big part of Team Duff’s cake is the water element. Deciding that the massive cake base is too large to use isomalt, lead cake decorator Geof Manthorne plays mad scientist with poured epoxy resin. The first attempt causes a chemical reaction with the silver dust and turns into a foam monstrosity spewing a toxic cloud that requires everyone including the film crew, to evacuate the premises. Geof’s further adventures in resin actually melt the foam board, requiring the base to be constructed again. Eventually, Duff suggests that they paint the board blue and tint 20 gallons of corn syrup a similar hue before carefully pouring it on the day of construction, which results in a spectacular effect.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Duff Goldman (@duffgoldman)

Team Buddy runs into similar challenges using isomalt for the first time on such a massive scale. Buddy, along with pastry chef Chad Durkin, and pastry chef and cake artist Mauro Castano, spend a gruelling day cooking and applying 300 pounds of isomalt to the cake base (a dangerous task, as the sugar reaches 300°F and literally melts the spatula Chad is using to stir it). As more isomalt gets applied in layers, the heavier it gets and starts falling off and shattering as it cools. Eventually, through patience and a lot of repair, the base is lit from behind with flickering lights, evoking the shimmer of the northern lights.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Buddy Valastro (@buddyvalastro)

;

Hidden Talents

Both teams get to bust out some secret moves this season. There’s the startling reveal that Ralph was in a production of the Nutcracker when he was 16, playing the rat king. Geof, when presented with his secret Santa present of pre-lit spheres, gives a quick demonstration of his juggling prowess.  Duff also gets to play with chainsaws, showing off his ice sculpting skills he honed at the Vail Cascade Hotel. “I used to carve ice in a previous life I haven’t done this since 1999, so we’ll see,” he says.

The Gifts That Keep Giving

Although the bake days are challenging and work-filled, both teams also take a little bit of a break to share in some holiday spirit. Natalie’s secret Santa present is a full “grandpa ensemble,” complete with cane, fake eyebrows and pipe, playing on her nickname and reputation as a cranky octogenarian.

The teams also send presents across the country to cheer each other up: Duff sends a basket of crab cakes, chowder and dips that Buddy pronounces “off the charts,” while Buddy sends a care package of his wife’s Eggplant Parmesan and a bunch of pastries and cake.

Related: The Evolution of Buddy Valastro: From Cake Boss to Buddy vs. Duff

“The pastries were gone in about 15 minutes, then we heated the eggplant parmesan, which was gone in about 12 minutes. And then everybody wanted to nap, because were all full of cheese,” laughs Duff. “Well played, Buddy. Well played.”

For more fun moments, watch Buddy vs. Duff Holiday. Stream all your favourite Food Network Canada shows through STACKTV with Amazon Prime Video Channels, or with the new Global TV app, live and on-demand when you sign-in with your cable subscription.

Host Buddy Valastro works on his team's "Winter Wonderland"-themed cake, as seen on Buddy vs Duff Holiday, Season 4.

Cake Boss Buddy Valastro is Bringing a Bakery to Toronto (Plus, He Shares His Fave Moments From Buddy vs. Duff Holiday)


“I’ve been literally working 18-hour days for the last month, says Buddy Valastro, AKA the Cake Boss, from the hit baking competition show Buddy vs. Duff.   “I’ve been actually sleeping in my office.” 

On the morning we caught up with Buddy, he is sitting in that office at his famed bakery in New Jersey – it’s his second interview and it’s only 9:30 AM.  The feeling with Buddy is immediately comfortable; he is friendly,  funny and down-to-earth, pulling you into the conversation as if you’ve known him personally for years.  On the show, the vibe he gives off is the same – but adds an element of toughness and perfectionism some would call having grit. Oh, did we mention that he is not shy about telling it like it is?

Host Buddy Valastro and his team, Ralph Attanasia, Mauro Castano, Anna Puchalski, Frankie Amato and Becky Blaso, as seen on Buddy vs Duff Holiday, Season 4.

Related: Watch the Holiday Season Trailer

What’s New This Season?

On this season of Buddy vs. Duff Holiday, Team Buddy and Team Duff (led by Duff Goldman) have to create seasonal-themed cakes inspired by things such as a winter wonderland, Santa’s workshop, The Nutcracker, and the Christmas cartoon classic, A Charlie Brown Christmas

While in the past seasons the cakes have been equally as impressive, the holidays add something magical to each episode, and for brief moments during the judging, you might forget that you’re looking at edible cakes. The designs are truly breathtaking!

“When you do this show, you get immersed into it and let me tell you, it’s like a month where you can think of nothing else but this,” says Buddy. “You know, I’m constantly pushing myself to come up with the most creative, insane cakes.”

And while there are lots of impressive elements to the cakes such as motorized parts and painting details, making sure that the cakes are edible is an important part of the cake-making and design process, reiterates Buddy.

“I can tell you that when I make a cake, I try to put as much cake in it as possible. There’s always going to be some structure. There’s always going to be some other side where you might have some Styrofoam. Any cake that we did on Buddy vs. Duff is at a minimum 300 pounds to 2000  pounds of cake, depending on how big it can be. For me, I want the viewer at home to always say, ‘When Buddy makes his cakes, it’s all cake,’ and  not just covered in Styrofoam or whatever.”

Related: Throwback to the First Season of Buddy vs. Duff

His Friendship With Duff

Host Duff Goldman shaves cake for table top, as seen on Buddy vs Duff, Season 4.

It might be hard to believe, but Buddy and Duff didn’t know each other until the first season of the show when they met on set. And like any relationship, it took time to build the friendship on and off the show over the past three years. Despite how TV may make it appear on the show at times, Buddy says the two have a great friendship.

I think we both have an appreciation and respect for cake decorating and we have our respect and appreciation for ourselves, each other and our teammates. I’m sure he wants to win at the end of the day. I’m sure I want to win at the end of the day, but it’s not in a bad way.”

Working With Family 

 

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Buddy Valastro (@buddyvalastro)

In this latest season, there is also a family connection – Buddy’s daughter, Sofia joins his team as a decorator. Working with his children is something Buddy says he enjoys and he hopes they follow in his footsteps if it they enjoy doing it.

“Right now, three out of my four children are in the back working and they’ve been working all the time,” says Buddy. “My son, Buddy, after he’s done with school, he drives to work and he stays because, you know, the way I act influences the people around me.

As for expanding the family business north of the border to Canada, Buddy says his new bakery is under construction in Toronto (details soon to come on Food Network Canada) and he hopes it to be open before Christmas.

Watch and stream Buddy vs. Duff Holiday and all your favourite Food Network Canada shows through STACKTV with Amazon Prime Video Channels, or with the new Global TV app, live and on-demand when you sign-in with your cable subscription. 

Buddy Valastro and his Carlo's Bakery team pose for a photo after winning Season 3 of Buddy vs. Duff

Buddy vs. Duff Season 3: The Best Moments

A close race right up until the very end, the third season of Buddy vs. Duff kept viewers in suspense with a completely tied score heading into the finale. Despite filming on both coasts with judges scattered across the country due to the pandemic, the rivalry was just as fierce in this East Coast/West Coast mashup. Both bakers also came into the competition changed by life circumstances: Buddy Valastro’s bowling accident that injured his dominant hand (a crucial tool for a baker) and the birth of Duff Goldman’s first child Josephine, with his wife Johnna.

Although Buddy took home the ultimate win with a 247-245 final score, the eight-episode season was filled with memorable moments from the Charm City Cakes and Carlo’s Bakery teams. Let’s take a look at a few of Season 3’s best moments.

Related: Meet the Cast of Buddy vs. Duff

A Return To The Classics: Episode 3, “Sweet Rides”

Calling back to an early challenge in Season 1, Duff suggested a rematch to redeem his team’s previously faulty hydraulics on a lowrider 64 Impala that he built with lead cake decorator Geof Manthorne. “It was a cool cake, but not our best work,” admitted Duff. This time, Duff and Geof had a team supporting them and went bigger and better with an eight-foot-long version showing off an LA bounce and working headlights and taillights. Ultimately, the car ended up losing narrowly by two points to Buddy’s fire engine red ’57 Chevy convertible, which impressed the judges with its detailed interior and stunning isomalt work.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Duff Goldman (@duffgoldman)


An Ace In The Hole: Episode 8, “Monster Matchup”

Secret weapon Laurent Branlard was a real ringer on the Carlo’s Bakery team, spinning out sugar work that wowed the judges time and time again. His glowing blown sugar spikes with a colour-changing light reflecting through them was a stunning game-changer on the team’s 20-foot long dinosaur. Not only did Laurent, an executive pastry chef, create 70 of these spikes (“I’m not going to lie —it’s pretty overwhelming,” he said), but he also found time to decorate them with disturbingly realistic lesions on the cake. “Who doesn’t dream about eating a pimple?”, he joked.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Buddy Valastro (@buddyvalastro)

Mishaps: All Season

From dropped trees on Duff’s hanging gardens to a tire blow-up on Buddy’s classic car, both teams had to deal with mishaps all through the season. During the Episode 4: First We Feast episode, both teams faced challenges in construction. As the Carlo’s Bakery crew moved their massive cake slice into the final area, Buddy got to do some last-minute repair when the sprinkles on the back started falling off, leading head sculptor Ralph Attanasia to dub Buddy the “Sprinkle Boss” and reducing the team to giggles. “We actually had a little disaster of it falling down and we had to redo it. I gotta be honest with you — the second time around, I think we did it better,” Buddy told the judges.

See More: The Best Moments From Season 2 of Buddy vs. Duff

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Buddy Valastro (@buddyvalastro)

On the Charm City Cakes side, homemade jelly jars made of isomalt filled with corn syrup were a great concept that had some issues with execution (trust Geof to hack a solution when the liquid springs a leak in the isomalt).

…And Machinery: All Season

Finally, who could forget the madcap machinations that occurred on both sides this season? Buddy’s love of his forklift (even executing a complicated cake flip that previously led to disaster in previous seasons) led pastry chef and cake artist Becky Blaso to comment, “Buddy always says go big or go home” when watching the mayhem. On the Charm City Cakes team, from Geof’s pivoting table belt that lifted the arms of nine-foot monster Marty to the lighting effect that animated the final cake, the team went all out to try new things. “Having the extra day gives us extra time to be extra dumb and dangerous,” observed Duff of Geof’s mad scientist lightning tube wiring.

Watch Buddy vs. Duff and stream your favourite Food Network Canada shows through STACKTV with Amazon Prime Video Channels, or with the new Global TV app, live and on-demand when you sign-in with your cable subscription.

Host Duff Goldman at Charm City Cakes with his arms folder and a smile on his face

The Evolution of Duff Goldman: From Ace of Cakes to Buddy vs. Duff

Duff Goldman became a household name with Ace of Cakes but soon, the success of the Food Network series inspired other cake shows and the landscape became sweetly saturated. Thankfully that was just beginning for this chef, who is also a bit of a rock star — he plays bass in the Elvis cover band Foie Grock, after all.

From emerging as the face of Charm City Cakes, to cookbooks, a handful of shows on Food Network Canada, and a very full personal life, it’s safe to say that Duff’s (dessert) plate is full. Let’s go back and see how it all began, shall we?

Watch Buddy vs. Duff Sunday at 9 PM ET/PT and stream all your favourite Food Network Canada shows through STACKTV with Amazon Prime Video Channels, or with the new Global TV app, live and on-demand when you sign-in with your cable subscription.

The Name of the Game

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Duff Goldman (@duffgoldman)

Jeffrey Adam Goldman was born in Detroit in 1974 before his family moved to Missouri. His nickname came from his older brother, Willie, who was unable to pronounce “Jeffrey.” Instead, “Duffy” became his new permanent nickname. Thank goodness. Not sure we could handle a Jeff and a Geof (Geoffrey Manthorne, Duff’s right hand man).

Easy as Cake

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Duff Goldman (@duffgoldman)

Duff’s been working in kitchens since he was 14. His first job was at a bagel store at the mall and eventually he became a fry cook at McDonald’s. In college, he applied to work as a cook at the Charleston, one of Baltimore’s finest restaurants, but head chef Cindy Wolf told him he lacked experience. She did, however, offer him a position making cornbread and biscuits. That was the turning point in his career.

Fine Art

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Duff Goldman (@duffgoldman)

Let’s not forget that Duff went to culinary school. Post-university (he has degrees in philosophy and history from the University of Maryland), Duff attended the Culinary Institute of America. It was there that he discovered his serious cake-making skills. He then worked at The French Laundry, run by renowned chef, restaurateur and cookbook author Thomas Keller. Under Keller’s leadership, Duff realized food and art could become one beautiful thing.

Business as Usual

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Duff Goldman (@duffgoldman)

Duff first launched his cake business in 2000, out of his Mount Vernon, Virginia apartment. There, he would make one cake a week, but as time went by his confections were becoming more in demand. Two years later he opened Charm City Cakes — this time out of a studio in Baltimore. By 2003, Duff sold $130,000 worth of cakes, nearly three times what he sold in his first year.

Show Time

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Duff Goldman (@duffgoldman)

Ace of Cakes was born in 2006. The show focused on the daily operations of Charm City Cakes as Duff and his equally fun and quirky staff went about their daily routines, constructing cakes using a variety of traditional and unconventional tools (like belt sanders, blowtorches and power saws). The show ran for 10 seasons over five years, coming to an end in 2011.

No Slowing Down

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Duff Goldman (@duffgoldman)

Ace of Cakes may have ended but that didn’t mean things were less busy for Duff. On the contrary, he opened his second bakery, this time in Los Angeles, which has the same Baltimore charm just in sunnier conditions. And more famous people.

Memory Lane

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Duff Goldman (@duffgoldman)

Some of the more memorable events Charm City Cakes has represented over the years were the premieres of Kung-Fu PandaHairspray and a couple of the Harry Potter movies, not to mention the times he was commissioned to make replicas of Radio City Music Hall, Wrigley Field, and the Hubble Space Telescope.

Love and Marriage

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Duff Goldman (@duffgoldman)

Duff and his then girlfriend Johnna Colbry dated for three years before they got married on Jan. 21, 2019. Naturally, there were three cakes at the ceremony: an underwater-themed creation that hung from the ceiling, a traditional white wedding cake for Johnna and a meat cake for Duff. That last concoction was memorable thanks to its bottom meatball tier, secondary meatloaf tier, lamb shawarma for the third tier, and scrapple on top. The frosting was mashed potatoes, bacon roses adorned the “icing,” and gravy cascaded from the chocolate fountain. Obviously.

Lights, Camera, so Much Action

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Duff Goldman (@duffgoldman)

Ace of Cakes may have taken up a lot of Duff’s precious baking time, but after a few years’ hiatus, the baker and chef returned to the small screen in 2014 with Kids Baking Championship. He quickly followed that up with Holiday Baking ChampionshipSpring Baking Championship and Duff Takes the Cake.

Putting Pen to Paper

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Duff Goldman (@duffgoldman)

Duff has always been willing to share the secrets to his success, which he does in cookbook form. The personality released his third title in Fall 2020, Super Good Baking For Kids. Previously he had also released  Ace of Cakes: Inside the World of Charm City Cakes and Duff Bakes: Think and Bake Like a Pro at Home.

Growing His Family

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Duff Goldman (@duffgoldman)

Duff’s third book may have been inspired by the fact that he was about to become a dad himself. In February 2021 Duff and Johnna welcomed baby girl Josephine to the world. “We made a family! I have a whole little family!” he wrote on social media at the time. “I keep telling Josephine about all the wonderful things she’s gonna get to try like pizza and candy and swimming and concerts and riding a bike.”

Merching Out

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Duff Goldman (@duffgoldman)

In addition to growing his business and his family, Duff has also gotten into the merchandising game. On his official site, he hocks plenty of branded t-shirts, beanies and baking accessories, allowing fans to bring a little of Duff into their own kitchens, too.

His Latest TV Adventure

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Duff Goldman (@duffgoldman)

Duff’s latest competition, Buddy vs. Duff, is now in its third season. Duff took the crown in Season 1 thanks to his seriously charming yet complex cakes, but Buddy Valastro rebounded in a big way to take home the win in Season 2. This season, everything will be on the line for these legendary cake artists, who hope to prove once and for all that they are the reigning cake champ.

Watch Buddy vs. Duff Sunday at 9 PM ET/PT and stream all your favourite Food Network Canada shows through STACKTV with Amazon Prime Video Channels, or with the new Global TV app, live and on-demand when you sign-in with your cable subscription.

Posted by Denette Wilford. Last Updated on August 22 by Amber Dowling.

Host Buddy Valastro talks to his team on the new season of Buddy vs. Duff.

The Evolution of Buddy Valastro: From Cake Boss to Buddy vs. Duff

Buddy Valastro has come a long way in a short time, from son of a baker to boss of all things baked. And while his personality has made for perfect television, Buddy still does what he does best: bakes elaborate and mouthwatering cakes that are treats for the mouth and the eyes. But while cakes may be his day job (thanks to Carlo’s Bakery), family is everything for the husband and father of four. His two cookbooks are all about famiglia and the fourth generation baker keeps those traditions going in his shops. Let’s take a walk down memory lane and explore the evolution of Buddy Valastro.

Watch Buddy vs. Duff Sunday at 10 PM ET/PT and stream all your favourite Food Network Canada shows through STACKTV with Amazon Prime Video Channels, or with the new Global TV app, live and on-demand when you sign-in with your cable subscription.

 Jersey Boy

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Buddy Valastro (@buddyvalastro)

Buddy was born in Hoboken, N.J. in 1977. The baby of the Valastro clan (he has four older sisters) began working at his family’s business, Carlo’s Bakery, at age 11, alongside his father, Buddy Sr. He took baking courses in high school, but the gene was already baked in his blood. Nothing was going to stop him from creating cakes and other amazing confections.

Shop Talk

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Buddy Valastro (@buddyvalastro)

Buddy’s dad passed away in 1994 when Buddy was 17. The son not only took over the shop but also succeeded his Pops as the new cake boss — literally.

Buddy’s Television Debut

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Buddy Valastro (@buddyvalastro)

The shop has made a name for itself by producing some of the most extravagant and grandiose cakes. Buddy made his first appearance on the Food Network in 2007, when he guest-mentored the “Battle of the Brides” episode of Food Network Challenge. But with his personality, it wouldn’t be the last we saw of him on-screen. In fact, it was just a taste.

Star Power

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Buddy Valastro (@buddyvalastro)

Carlo’s Bakery is known for creating cakes for any occasion that are devoured by celebrities (from Britney, to Gigi, to Beyoncé, to Big Bird) and ordinary Joes alike.

The Big Time

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Buddy Valastro (@buddyvalastro)

In 2009, his series – the aptly named Cake Boss – premiered on TLC and ran for eight seasons. It spawned several spinoffs including Next Great BakerKitchen BossBakers vs. Fakers and Buddy’s Family Vacation, which featured Buddy, wife Lisa and their four kids — Sofia, Buddy Jr., Marco and Carlo — as they embarked on an RV road trip across America in search of delicious eats and fun-filled adventures.

Sweet Street

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Buddy Valastro (@buddyvalastro)

Carlo’s Bakery was actually founded by Italian pastry chef Carlo Guastaferro in 1910 before he sold it to Buddy’s father in 1964. In 2010, in honour of the bakery’s 100th anniversary, Hoboken renamed the corner of where the shop sits (Washington and Newark Streets) to Carlo’s Bakery Way.

A Tough Personal Loss

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Buddy Valastro (@buddyvalastro)

In 2017 Buddy suffered a huge personal blow when the family lost their matriarch, Mary Valastro. The 69-year-old had been diagnosed with ALS, also known as Lou Gehrig’s disease, and she put up a good fight. “She is no longer suffering and I hope she’s dancing to ‘I Will Survive’ with my dad right now,” Buddy shared on social media at the time.

A Rivalry Was Born 

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Buddy Valastro (@buddyvalastro)

The brilliant idea of pitting Buddy against Ace of Cakes’ Duff Goldman was an epic baking battle that couldn’t be denied. They may be baking royalty but their styles are very different as Buddy’s cakes tend to be huge and filled with all kinds of personality, while Duff’s are meticulously detailed. In any case, Buddy vs. Duff was born, and one thing was clear: Buddy didn’t like it when he lost to Duff—he didn’t like it one little bit.

Host With the Most

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Buddy Valastro (@buddyvalastro)

Buddy may have been licking those frosted-filled wounds following the first season of Buddy vs. Duff, but he was too busy to dwell on the loss for long. The 43-year-old couldn’t be a more perfect host for the series Bake You Rich, which saw four bakers competing to become a household name. Each episode’s victor found their winning creation available to order at Carlo’s Bakery. Now that’s sweet!

Ace of Cupcakes

Buddy broke his own Guinness World Record in October 2019 when he appeared on Live! With Kelly and Ryan and iced even more cupcakes in one minute than he did earlier in the year.

Buddy vs. Duff: Take Two

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Buddy Valastro (@buddyvalastro)

Duff may have taken Season 1 of Buddy vs. Duff but Buddy had something to prove in the show’s second season. He and his team mounted an epic comeback with some of the biggest cake creations we’ve ever seen, evening out the score between these two bakers by taking home the win.

A Tragic Accident

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Buddy Valastro (@buddyvalastro)

Buddy’s victory was short-lived when, in September 2020, he mangled his hand in a gruesome freak accident while bowling with his family. The bowling pinsetter malfunctioned, and a metal rod impaled his hand. The ace baker then underwent five reconstructive surgeries and physical therapy, and today he says he feels back to 90-95 per cent.

Ready for Round 3

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Buddy Valastro (@buddyvalastro)

With Buddy and Duff tied at one win apiece, there’s a lot on the line as we head into Buddy vs. Duff Season 3. This time around the challenges are tougher than ever, but both personalities seem ready to prove that they have what it takes to outdo the other. And as far as we’re concerned, we can’t wait to see how it all plays out.

Watch Buddy vs. Duff Sunday at 9 PM ET/PT and stream all your favourite Food Network Canada shows through STACKTV with Amazon Prime Video Channels, or with the new Global TV app, live and on-demand when you sign-in with your cable subscription.

Posted by Denette Wilford. Last Updated on August 9 by Amber Dowling.

9 Memorable Moments From Buddy vs. Duff — Plus, the Season Two Winner Revealed

The batter has been poured, the cakes have been sculpted, and the second season of Buddy vs. Duff is in the (flour) bag. Over eight episodes the Carlo’s Bakery and Charm City Cakes owners have gone head-to-head in a flurry of challenges, proving they really are the crème de la butter-crème when it comes to larger-than-life cakes. Here are all of our favourite season two moments leading up to and including the Buddy vs Duff finale, when the judges named this year’s ultimate winner.

Duff Decorates the Inside of a Cake

Riding high on his first season win, Duff was ready to pull out all the stops in the first episode when the guys were asked to create a New York City cake that showed off their best interpretation skills. And while Buddy went big and recreated the Statue of Liberty, Duff dug into the details of St. Patrick’s Cathedral. Most of those details just happened to be inside of the cake itself, and the judges could only see those beautiful arches and stained glass through a camera. In the end, those details earned the baker the extra half-a-point he needed to take the first challenge win, but one thing was clear: this was going to be a close season full of next-level cakes.

Buddy vs Duff season 2 episode 1 winner

Forklifts Are the New Stand Mixer

Proving that bigger is actually sometimes better, Buddy set the tone in the dinosaur sleepover challenge when the guys were asked to tackle realism and dinos. Not only did Buddy recreate a life-size creature with amazing eyeballs and textured skin (thanks to the help of some gumballs), but the crew needed a forklift just to lift the thing. It wasn’t the last time Buddy used the machine to help crate his creations around throughout the season, proving that next-level bakers need next-level tools.

Buddy vs. Duff season 2 episode 2 winner

Related: The Evolution of Buddy Valastro 

Duff Pulls Off a Horse, Because of Course

When Buddy had the lead heading into episode three, Duff realized he needed to up his own game for the medieval feast challenge. So when the judges told them to hone in on special effects, he and his team built a gigantic horse that transformed into a unicorn and farted glitter. Not only are horses one of the hardest bakes to pull off to begin with, but this creation was so big that Duff and Co. couldn’t even get it out the door without disassembling it first.

Buddy vs Duff season 2 episode 3 winner

Everyone Recreates Jordin Sparks

It has to be super trippy to see yourself in cake form, but Jordin Sparks was seeing double in the Waitress musical challenge when the guys were tasked with creating a tableau that best described the play. Buddy’s team opted for a cute caricature while Duff’s team did a life-size recreation, and while both offerings had Sparks tearing up it was Duff’s cake that pulled out the big W.

Buddy vs. Duff season 2 episode 4 winner

Duff Loses to the Clock

When the teams headed to the aquarium to pull off some swimming aquatic cakes, Duff got up in his head when he realized he may have overshot his cake—especially when he saw Buddy’s impressive three-tonne whale bake. So with dozens of details still not complete at the 48-hour mark, Duff kept working and wound up taking a two-point time penalty. As a result, Buddy earned five total extra points that week, propelling him to an easy win.

Buddy vs Duff season 2 episode 5 winner

Related: The Evolution of Duff Goldman

The Air Conditioner Goes Bust

Duff was feeling the pressure heading into the mini golf challenge and admitted he was pretty thirsty for some redemption after the aquatic kerfuffle. So he went with an oceanside theme for his hole, which quickly went awry when the air conditioner at his shop went bust and his cakes started melting. Buddy, meanwhile, created a Carlo’s Bakery theme with dozens of cakes and an impressive storefront sign, easily beating Duff once again.

Buddy vs. Duff season 2 episode 6 winner

Team Duff Takes a Camera Detox

With two tough losses under his iced belt, Duff was in his feelings by the time the guys got around to the amusement park challenge and they were asked to incorporate movement into their cakes. Both teams went for carousels, but in a surprise move, Team Duff went dark. Turns out the baker just really needed to be able to focus on the fun of creating with his team, and so he turned the cameras around. As a result, for the first time all season, neither Buddy nor the judges could see what he was up to.

Buddy Makes the Most Interactive Cake Yet

Meanwhile over on Team Buddy, the baker decided to go all-in and make a carousel cake that the judges could also ride. Enter that famous forklift and a whole lot of stress, because if that thing wasn’t properly designed it could actually end up seriously hurting someone. They pulled it off in the end, but it wasn’t enough to top Duff’s top-secret cake, which shot out popcorn and won by a whopping three points.

Buddy vs. Duff season 2 episode 7 winner

Related: 10 Moments From Buddy vs. Duff Season One That Had Us on the Edge of Our Seast

Buddy Takes the Cake

Heading into the finale Buddy had an impressive six-point lead, but with two Star Wars-themed cakes on the line that had to incorporate all of the previous skills, the pressure was on. Buddy impressed with a recreation of the Millennium Falcon and a laser show that the audience was certainly there for, but in the end, Buddy’s X-wing tableau with an amazingly sculpted Yoda was the cake of the night. However, Duff’s win wasn’t enough to overcome a tough season full of surprise mishaps, and in the end, Buddy got the ultimate redemption when he was named season two winner.

So that’s one season win for Duff, and one season win for Buddy. It seems like a third-season tie-breaker is inevitable, no? Well there’s no news just quite yet, but one thing is clear: people definitely need more jaw-dropping cakes from this duo.

Buddy vs Duff season 2 episode 8 winner

Watch Buddy vs. Duff Sunday and stream all your favourite Food Network Canada shows through STACKTV with Amazon Prime Video Channels, or with the new Global TV app, live and on-demand when you sign-in with your cable subscription.

 

Buddy vs. Duff

Buddy vs. Duff: See Buddy Valastro and Duff Goldman’s Most Epic Cakes

In Buddy vs. Duff, legendary bakers Buddy Valastro and Duff Goldman will bring their culinary A-game as they face off in a series of dessert-themed challenges. The battling bakers will compete in a final space-themed task, where the judges will crown the winner and settle this epic feud once and for all. For a (visual) taste of what you cake expect to see from the series, we’ve kicked off the competition early, showcasing some of the most epic baked creations from Buddy and Duff. May the best baker win!

Buddy’s a pro at bringing animals to life

This sea-creature-inspired cake has our eyes go from the Hammerhead shark breaking through the top-most tier to the eel weaving it’s way through the middle section, all the way to the colorful collection of underwater life and seashells scattered all around the base of this cake. From shading to texture, we just can’t get over how detailed every creature on this cake is up-close!

Duff is all about the details when it comes to scene-style cakes

This elaborate city-scape cake created by Duff and his team called for 150 pounds of cake and 50 pounds of fondant. There is so much going on here, from a “just married” car and mini wedding cake to the hot air balloon — can you spot the sailboat?

Buddy is a master chef when it comes to barbeque baking

This cake, dubbed “House of Que”, looks so good; you would think it was the real deal. We’ll take a side of ribs, please!

Duff is always looking to up the ante

Never to be outdone, Duff takes the barbeque-baking concept to the next level, with his massive and ultra-realistic steak-cake, created with the Baltimore Ravens logo seemingly seared into the fondant. We love how detailed this cake is, from the meat-like texture created with shading and colouring, to the T-bone design that really completes the illusion of a real steak.

Buddy has a musical side – or at least his cakes do

Buddy created this amazing guitar-themed cake as a birthday tribute to musical icon Willie Nelson. The hand-painted details make this creation a true work of art — just look at the (intentional) signs of “wear and tear” and signature designs added to mimic Willie’s real guitar.

No one does a large-scale cake quite like Duff

This behemoth of a stadium-themed cake, designed to mimic the real deal and created for the US Open Grand Slam Tennis Tournament in 2010, has onlookers in awe as Duff adds the final touches. We love how Duff was able to mimic crowds in the stands, and have you seen the extra design elements outside of the stadium piece?

Buddy’s a builder – with fondant, at least

View this post on Instagram

Having so fun @marylandlive how do you like my cake?

A post shared by Buddy Valastro (@buddyvalastro) on

Channeling his inner urban planner, Buddy crafted this true-to-life urban landscape for Maryland Live, and judging by the look on his face — he seems pretty happy with the results. We don’t blame him — the buildings, roadways and even greenery that sit atop the base of this giant cake all look like the real-deal.

Duff creates the stuff of (Marvel) legends

Would you believe this giant Hulk recreation is in fact, a fully-edible cake? Believe it! The mean green machine himself was built up as a cake and presented by Duff to the Stan Lee in 2014 at Comikaze Expo. Duff recently reposed this epic throwback creation as a tribute to the late Marvel Comics legend.

Buddy serves up the best of both worlds

View this post on Instagram

????

A post shared by Buddy Valastro (@buddyvalastro) on

If you struggle with satisfying your sweet tooth while also getting your daily fruit-fix, Buddy’s got the solution with this delicious watermelon cake. All cake and icing on the outside, with juicy, ripened watermelon on the inside. Now this is a summertime treat to get excited about!

Duff makes the donut cake of all donut cakes

Helping Krispy Kreme celebrate their 81st birthday – and the launch of a new donut flavor – is no easy task, but judging by this cake, Duff is up to the challenge. This donut-covered cake looks too good to be true… mind if we have a piece, Duff?

Tune in to Buddy vs. Duff Sundays at 10:00 PM E/P.